1. Electronics & Gadgets

Canon EOS 5D Mark II DSLR Camera User Review

Reader Reviews: User Reviews of Canon Cameras

User Rating 4 Star Rating

From Lowell Baker

Canon EOS 5D Mark II DSLR Camera User Review

FAVORITE PHOTO TAKEN WITH THIS CAMERA: Frozen tree in Republic, Wash.

Name of product: 

Canon EOS 5D Mark II DSLR

Approximate date of purchase: 

August 2010

My Review 

The Canon 5D has many options and really requires you to have a really updated computer to run the video from the camera, unless you are just plugging directly into your HDTV. I found the CMOS sensor lacking as compared to Nikon. My daughter has a D90 form Nikon, and she has taken some pictures that are far better than the Canon in sharpness and overall color balance. If you combined both cameras, then you really would have something to brag about. I have always been looking for a digital camera that would be close to film. The overall package of the 5D Mark II is pretty good, but I was still disappointed after spending $4,300 on the camera and an L series lens. I shoot closeups for displays and life-scape nature pictures. Yes, I may just be too picky in what I expect from a digital camera, but, after shooting pictures for 30 years for seminars, I know what I like.

The best thing you can do is go with a memory card to the store, shoot some pictures, and go home and play with them on your computer. That is the only way you will be able to make the choice that suits your camera needs. The Canon is a fine camera and has performed very well except for when we first got it. I set out on an $8,000 trip to northern Idaho, and the camera had a complete memory board failure. Now this is something that came from the factory, not dropping the camera, which I have never done with any camera in 40 years of taking pictures. Canon would not let me exchange it with a local Canon dealer. Fortunately, I had a backup camera to take my nature and creation pictures. The camera, I would rate at a "B+" in what I expect in picture quality. Canon's Service gets a complete "F-". Their attitude was: "We do not care if your camera failed on your $8,000 trip. Just send it into Irvine and we will fix it. That is all we are going to do. Even though there was a certified Canon distributor that could have exchanged the camera that was only 80 miles away, not 1,400 miles away. I even called the dealer and, yes, he had one in stock. So, I guess if you want customer service, check the Internet and see what the manufacturer offers for replacement if your equipment fails.

Camera "pros" 

Very well built overall.

Camera "cons" 

Picture quality was not what I thought a $2,500 camera body should deliver.

Is this camera easy to use? 

About average

How is the image quality in good lighting? 

Shoots great photos

How is the image quality when using the flash? 

About average

Do you like the camera's style and feel? 

No, too large or heavy

How is the camera's LCD screen? 

About average

Do you feel like the camera is/was a good value? 

I don't know

Would you recommend this to a friend? 

No

Kyle Schurman, Digital Cameras Guide, says:

Sorry to hear about your problems with the 5D, but thanks for sharing your thoughts and for being so honest! That should be helpful for some other people.

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.